Skip to content

Welcome to our store

  • Home
  • Product Catalog
  • Contact
  • Whatnot Live Breaks
Log in
    CritMonkey Collectibles
    • Home
    • Product Catalog
    • Contact
    • Whatnot Live Breaks
    Log in Cart

    Item added to your cart

    View cart
    Remove all
    Filter Filter

    Filter

    Filter

    9464 products

    Remove all
    Remove all

    9464 products

    • 1951 Topps Red Backs #22 Bob Feller

      1951 Topps Red Backs #22 Bob Feller

      1951 Topps Red Backs #22 Bob Feller

      Regular price $50.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $50.00 USD
    • 1954 Bowman #35 Eddie Joost Quiz Answer Is 33 PSA 2

      1954 Bowman #35 Eddie Joost Quiz Answer Is 33 PSA 2

      1954 Bowman #35 Eddie Joost Quiz Answer Is 33 PSA 2

      Regular price $48.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $48.00 USD
    • 1954 Topps #131 Reno Bertoia PSA 2

      1954 Topps #131 Reno Bertoia PSA 2

      1954 Topps #131 Reno Bertoia PSA 2

      Regular price $35.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $35.00 USD
    • 1955 Topps #119 Bob Lennon PSA 4

      1955 Topps #119 Bob Lennon PSA 4

      1955 Topps #119 Bob Lennon PSA 4

      Regular price $46.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $46.00 USD
    • 1955 Topps #140 Mel Parnell PSA 4

      1955 Topps #140 Mel Parnell PSA 4

      1955 Topps #140 Mel Parnell PSA 4

      Regular price $46.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $46.00 USD
    • 1956 Topps #297 Bob Skinner PSA 4

      1956 Topps #297 Bob Skinner PSA 4

      1956 Topps #297 Bob Skinner PSA 4

      Regular price $46.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $46.00 USD
    • 1956 Topps #306 Curt Roberts PSA 1.5

      1956 Topps #306 Curt Roberts PSA 1.5

      1956 Topps #306 Curt Roberts PSA 1.5

      Regular price $35.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $35.00 USD
    • 1956 Topps #41 Hank Sauer White Back PSA 3

      1956 Topps #41 Hank Sauer White Back PSA 3

      1956 Topps #41 Hank Sauer White Back PSA 3

      Regular price $35.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $35.00 USD
    • 1956 Topps #46 Gene Freese White Back PSA 4

      1956 Topps #46 Gene Freese White Back PSA 4

      1956 Topps #46 Gene Freese White Back PSA 4

      Regular price $35.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $35.00 USD
    • 1956 Topps #60 Mayo Smith White Back PSA 4

      1956 Topps #60 Mayo Smith White Back PSA 4

      1956 Topps #60 Mayo Smith White Back PSA 4

      Regular price $35.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $35.00 USD
    • 1956 Topps #94 Ronnie Kline White Back PSA 5

      1956 Topps #94 Ronnie Kline White Back PSA 5

      1956 Topps #94 Ronnie Kline White Back PSA 5

      Regular price $46.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $46.00 USD
    • 1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays PSA 4

      1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays PSA 4

      1958 Topps #5 Willie Mays PSA 4

      Regular price $250.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $250.00 USD
    • 1959 Topps #349 Hoyt Wilhelm

      1959 Topps #349 Hoyt Wilhelm

      1959 Topps #349 Hoyt Wilhelm

      Regular price $6.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
    • 1959 Topps #359 Bill White

      1959 Topps #359 Bill White

      1959 Topps #359 Bill White

      Regular price $6.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
    • 1959 Topps #428 Buc Hill Aces Kline/Friend/Law/Face PSA 5

      1959 Topps #428 Buc Hill Aces Kline/Friend/Law/Face PSA 5

      1959 Topps #428 Buc Hill Aces Kline/Friend/Law/Face PSA 5

      Regular price $46.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $46.00 USD
    • 1960 Topps #100 Nellie Fox

      1960 Topps #100 Nellie Fox

      1960 Topps #100 Nellie Fox

      Regular price $6.00 USD
      Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • …
    • 592

    Subscribe to our emails

    Payment methods
    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Diners Club
    • Discover
    • Google Pay
    • Mastercard
    • PayPal
    • Shop Pay
    • Visa
    © 2025, CritMonkey Collectibles Powered by Shopify
    • Privacy policy
    • Refund policy
    • Terms of service
    • Shipping policy
    • Contact information
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
    • Opens in a new window.